Suitest Taboo Chronicles Blog

substitution is by no means a replacement of the original – if you hate us, we love you –

YG Entertainment responds: G-Dragon’s case


So YG Entertainment finally responds to all those lowly accusations of plagiarism. And well, we’re not gonna copy and paste the whole thing so you’re gonna have to read it on allkpop. What we will do though is take excerpts and plant our little comments after them.

Where does YG stand in this plagiarism issue?
In my opinion, all the arguments and discussions could be seen different depending on the views and the viewers. So, I cannot explain my personal opinion of whether it was influenced by other songs or not.

However, in the centre of attention, there is “Heartbreaker”. This issue emerged above the surface because it had similar rap-flow as Flo Rida’s “Right Round”. Right Round is an extremely famous song even in Korea, and recently another Korean artist has sung it with translation, and appeared on the media. It is impossible that the composers at YG and G-Dragon tried to go around their way to plagiarise. It is impossible, because with the internet and all, everything gets revealed quickly.

Many expressed their concerns, “Why did G-Dragon do this? For the rappers who write and rap, it shouldn’t be hard to fix a few verses and re-recording”, and “How come did Yang Hyun-Seok, Teddy, Perry and Kush never mention that to G-Dragon?” It isn’t because we were trying to fool the public, but the other way around. I did not expect such a stir among the public, and I think I should be 100 folds more responsible than G-Dragon as the executive producer. I am truly sorry to G-Dragon and his fans who are burdened alone.

Okay one, as much as I love YG and G-Dragon, can they honestly say it’s pure coincidence that the bgm, melody and rhyme are exactly the same? He said it himself that Right Round is very popular in Korea, so the chances of them not hearing this song on several occasions is highly unlikely. Also, how can they not expect that type of stir from the public? G-Dragon personally put up the 30 second sample on his me2day, especially that part. Why that part? He couldn’t put the chorus? And while I feel for Yang Hyun-Seok taking full responsibility, G-Dragon is at fault because with his musicality, he should have known that the sample he put online is the same exact sample from another song.

There are sayings that this issue is part of the marketing for YG.
First of all, YG is not that clever to come up with a marketing plan like this. Especially for G-Dragon, he was receiving enough attention as the leader of a famous idol group in Korea, and for releasing his ever-first solo album. He is even cutting off the appearance on the stage…

I laugh at this because that’s an insult to his marketing department. If you were in YG‘s marketing department wouldn’t you feel insulted at the fact that he just called you incompetent? While our previous posts do say that we wouldn’t be surprised if it was a marketing ploy, we still wouldn’t put it past anyone there. The industry is shady, the workers are smart they just hide it. One can inadvertently come up with something like this situation as a marketing ploy and not even realize it. It happens to everyone, they say something, its done, but then at the same time they don’t even realize what was done.

I’m sure GD thought it would be harmless to release that sample, especially as a gift to his fans to get a taste. But this ‘sample‘, that ‘teaser‘, in essence is subliminal marketing. One release’s samples to get the fans hyped, to get new people to listen; in the end it’s marketing – promoting.

While there is a lot more to the statement that YG released, I’m only touching basis on these two points. Why? Because for the most part I agree with YG in his statement.

We’re not saying that YG and GD did plagiarize, because we don’t think they did. But we do keep an open mind and need to play devil’s advocate. Not everything is black and white when it comes to the entertainment industry. People and fans alike need to realize that there are always two sides to a story, and while we have our opinions, our job is to report and let you, the readers come up with your own conclusions.

Filed under: Drama, Entertainment, gossip, Issues, K-Pop, Korea, Korean Entertainment, News, rumors, Scandalous, YG entertainment, , , ,

The truth about ‘Heartbreaker’ Part III


Just a little more ‘I really don’t care’ about this issue news.

The owner’s of Flo rida’sRight Round” and Oasis’ “She’s electric” have made some statements regarding G-Dragon‘s supposed plagiarism.

They stated, “The 10 composers to ‘Right Round’ have not all expressed their opinion on this issue until. We had sent samples of GDragon’s songs to the parties involved for the 2 songs ‘Right Round’ and ‘She’s Electric.” Also, “There are indeed similarities between ‘Heartbreaker’ and ‘Right Round’ and between ‘Butterfly’ and ‘She’s Electric’. It is hard to say if it is plagiarism at this stage. We will all go with the final decision of the composers to the song.”*

Sony ATV commented that, “Sampling and remaking of a song by using part of the original should be allowed; but sampling without permission is not. The individual should try his/her best to make their own music/work every-time, so as to protect the copyright of others’ works. The piece of work should be the creator’s own expression and not just the idea or title.”*

All that means is that they should just use the original as inspiration. They do have a point though with the following trend. Many artists recycle beats, if they really want to get into it, they should come back to America and sue half of the artists now because at least 75% of the music has recycled beats. I can’t even begin to tell you how many songs I’ve heard on the radio and thought it was one song but in fact it was another.

Also there is this thing about following trend. There may be cases when people or music experts will listen to a song A and think that it plagiarises song B, but that is because listening to it makes one think about the special characteristics of song B.”*

If they’re going to say that G-Dragon plagiarized, then Teddy, GD and who ever worked on Big Bang‘s Haru Haru, Lies and Heaven needs to get on LMFAO butt for literally taking those songs and re-making it into “La La La“. If any of you who listen to that song and don’t hear Big Bang, you need to clean your ears.

About GD‘s naked girl shirt, you go boy. Who cares if he has a shirt of a naked woman? He’s a grown man, of age and probably wants some of his own. He’s crying out for help; if wearing a naked woman on a shirt is as close as he’s gonna get to a naked woman right now, let the guy be please. K Thanks.

Everyone, try to be open minded. Anti’s try to get a life and stop meddling in the lives of people who you wish were friends with or jealous of. Karma sucks you know.

cited: sookyeong@kbites

Filed under: Drama, Entertainment, gossip, Issues, K-Pop, Korea, Korean Entertainment, rumors, Scandalous, YG entertainment, , , , , , , , , , ,